How To Stain Wood Countertops So They Look Fresh And Amazing

Staining Success: Transform Your Wood Countertops with Ease

Have you ever looked at your kitchen’s countertops and thought, “Could these look better?”

Or maybe you’ve pondered, “How can I protect these surfaces and still maintain that natural charm?” If these questions have crossed your mind, you’re in the right place.

In this post, we’re going to walk you through the art of staining wood countertops, a skill that’s both practical and rewarding for any South Lyon homeowner.

You’ll learn how to choose the right materials and finishes, prepare your countertops for staining, and apply the stain and sealer like a pro.

By the end of this guide, you’ll not only have countertops that look fantastic but also the satisfaction of having done it yourself.

However, if you prefer a professional touch, follow the link to explore Tribble Painting Company’s services in South Lyon.

Get ready to give your kitchen a stunning makeover that’s both functional and stylish!

Choosing the Right Material and Finish

When it comes to enhancing your kitchen or any other space with wood countertops, the first step is selecting the right material.

Butcher block, known for its durability and warm aesthetic, is a popular choice among South Lyon residents.

It’s not just about picking any butcher block; it’s about finding the one that resonates with your home’s style and your personal preference.

Selecting Your Wood Countertop Material

In the realm of butcher block counters, you’ll encounter a variety of woods, each offering its unique grain and color.

Maple and oak are common choices, offering a balance of hardness and aesthetic appeal.

Consider the wood grain, as it not only contributes to the appearance but also impacts the longevity and maintenance of your countertops.

In the video below, we stain a maple desktop, but the process is essentially the same for butcher block counters.

Oil vs. Polyurethane Finishing

Once you’ve chosen your butcher block, deciding on the finish is crucial.

If you’re leaning towards a natural look and feel, oil finishes like tung oil or mineral oil are excellent choices.

They penetrate deep into the wood, enhancing the wood grain and offering a food-safe surface.

However, they require more maintenance to prevent warping and keep the wood conditioned.

On the other hand, polyurethane provides a more durable finish.

It creates a protective layer that guards against stains and water damage, making it a practical choice for busy kitchens.

While it’s not food-safe, it’s a robust option for those who don’t plan to use their butcher block countertop as a cutting board.

In the video below, we use a polyurethane finish, which is perfect for a wood surface that is not being used for food preparation.

How to Stain Wood Countertops in 9 Steps

Duration: Approximately 24 hours

Difficulty: Beginner


  • Sandpaper (60-grit & 220-grit)

  • Orbital sander

  • Tack cloth

  • Brushes for applying stain and sealer

  • Multiple rags


  • Wood glue

  • Sealer: mineral or tung oil, or polyurethane (we use polyurethane in the video below)

  • Drop cloths

  • Painter’s tape

1. Prep the Area

Before staining a wood surface, it’s crucial to properly prepare the surrounding area to ensure a clean and efficient process.

Start by covering the floor and nearby furniture with drop cloths or plastic sheeting to protect them from any accidental spills or drips.

Cover any small components near the wood surface with blue painter’s tape.

Additionally, ensure good ventilation in the working area by opening windows or using fans, as this helps in reducing the fumes from the stain and speeds up the drying process.

2. Sanding the Surface

Next, sand the surface of your butcher block countertop or other wood surface.

Using an orbital sander, begin with a coarser grit sandpaper ( such as 60-grit) and gradually move to a finer grit (such as 220-grit).

This process smooths the surface and prepares it for staining, ensuring the stain adheres evenly.

3. Filling Cracks and Imperfections

If your butcher block has any cracks or imperfections, now is the time to address them.

Mix wood glue with the sawdust created during sanding to make a putty.

This custom filler not only matches the color of your wood but also helps maintain the integrity of the countertop.

Remember to sand down the filler after it dries.

The desktop in the video above did not have any cracks or significant imperfections, so we moved straight to staining after the sanding step.

4. Easing the Corners (optional step)

For a more finished look, consider easing the corners of your butcher block.

A simple sanding can round off sharp edges, giving a more polished appearance and reducing the chances of splinters or chips.

In the next section, we’ll dive into the staining process, guiding you through each step to achieve that perfect finish for your countertops.

Stay tuned as we explore the world of stains, from choosing the right shade to mastering the application technique.

Choosing Your Stain

The first step in the staining process is selecting the right type of stain for your wood.

You have two primary options: oil-based stain and water-based stain.

Oil-based stains are known for their durability and rich coloration, enhancing the natural wood grain of your surface.

However, they are not food safe, making them a better choice for counters not used as cutting surfaces.

Water-based stains, on the other hand, are a bit more environmentally friendly and have a faster drying time.

They’re less odorous and can retain the natural color of the wood more effectively.

If you’re looking for a food-safe option and plan to use your butcher block countertop as a cutting board, consider using mineral oil or tung oil.

These oils penetrate deeply, protecting the wood while keeping it safe for food preparation.

5. Applying the Stain

Once you’ve chosen your stain, it’s time to apply it to your butcher block.

Start by ensuring your wood is clean and dry.

Using a clean rag or a foam brush, apply the stain in long, even strokes, going along with the wood grain.

This technique helps in achieving a smooth, uniform coat.

After applying a thick coat of stain, let it sit for a while to penetrate the wood fibers.

The duration can vary depending on the type of stain and the desired final color.

Generally, letting the stain sit for about 15 minutes works well.

Then, using a clean rag, wipe off any excess stain.

This step is crucial to avoid uneven patches or a sticky surface.

6. Letting the Stain Dry

Patience is key when it comes to letting the stain dry.

Rushing this process can lead to a less than satisfactory finish.

Allow the stained butcher block to dry completely, which might take overnight or longer, depending on the humidity and temperature in your South Lyon home.

7. Applying Additional Coats (optional)

For a deeper color and enhanced protection, you might want to apply additional coats of stain.

Lightly sand the surface with fine-grit sandpaper between coats to ensure a smooth base.

Remember to remove all sanding dust with a tack cloth before applying the next coat.

Repeat the staining process until you achieve the richness and depth of color you absolutely love.

In the next section, we’ll delve into sealing your newly stained butcher block countertops, an essential step to protect your beautiful work and extend the life of your counters.

Stay tuned for more tips and tricks to perfect your South Lyon kitchen’s centerpiece.

Choosing the Right Sealer

When it comes to sealing butcher block countertops, you have a few options.

If you’ve used a food-safe oil like mineral oil or tung oil for staining, these oils also act as natural sealers.

They penetrate the wood, providing a protective layer while keeping the surface safe for food preparation.

For those who have opted for a non-food-safe stain, such as an oil-based stain, a polyurethane sealer is a popular choice.

It forms a durable, water-resistant layer that’s ideal for busy kitchens.

You can choose between a matte or glossy finish, depending on your personal preference and the style of your kitchen.

8. Applying Polyurethane

If you’re going with polyurethane, the application process is straightforward but requires attention to detail.

Start by ensuring your stained butcher block is completely dry.

Using a foam brush, apply the polyurethane in long, even strokes, covering the entire surface.

This method helps in achieving a smooth, streak-free finish.

After applying the first coat, let it dry completely.

Drying time may depend on the humidity and temperature, but we recommend leaving it overnight to dry.

Once the first coat is dry, lightly sand the surface with fine-grit sandpaper.

This step is crucial as it prepares the surface for the second coat, ensuring better adhesion and a smoother finish.

Wipe the surface with a tack cloth to remove any sanding dust.

Then, apply the second coat of polyurethane.

For added durability, you might consider applying a third coat, especially on areas of the countertop that will see heavy use, like near the sink or stove.

9. Letting the Polyurethane Cure

Patience is essential when it comes to letting the polyurethane cure.

Rushing this process can compromise the durability and appearance of your seal.

Allow the final coat to dry completely, which could take up to 24 hours or more.

Once fully cured, your butcher block countertops will be ready to face the daily demands of your South Lyon kitchen.

In the next section, we’ll cover the maintenance and care of your newly stained and sealed butcher block countertops, ensuring they remain a stunning feature in your home for years to come.

Stay tuned for practical tips and tricks to keep your countertops looking as good as new.

Maintaining the Beauty of Your Wooden Countertops

After investing time and effort into staining and sealing your butcher block countertops, maintaining their beauty and functionality is key.

In South Lyon, where homes blend style and practicality, keeping your butcher block in top condition is essential.

Here’s how to ensure your countertops remain a highlight in your kitchen.

Regular Cleaning and Care

The secret to long-lasting butcher block countertops lies in regular, gentle cleaning.

For daily maintenance, a simple wipe with a clean, damp cloth is sufficient.

Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners, as they can damage the wood’s surface.

If you need a bit more cleaning power, a mild dish soap solution works wonders.

For wooden countertops used as cutting surfaces, it’s crucial to clean them after each use, especially when handling raw food.

A solution of water and white vinegar is excellent for sanitizing the surface without harming the wood.

Tackling Stains and Spills

Accidents happen, and spills are inevitable, especially in a bustling kitchen.

When dealing with spills, act quickly to prevent stains from setting in.

For stubborn stains, a paste made from baking soda and water can be gently rubbed onto the affected area.

Rinse thoroughly and dry with a clean rag.

Oiling and Conditioning

Regular oiling is recommended to keep your wooden countertops looking their best.

Food-safe oils like mineral oil or tung oil not only enhance the wood grain but also protect the surface from drying out and cracking.

Apply the oil using a clean rag, ensuring even coverage.

Let the oil sit for a few hours, or even overnight, then wipe off any excess oil with a clean cloth.

If you’ve used a polyurethane seal, oiling isn’t necessary, but keeping the surface clean and dry will help maintain its shine and durability.

Refinishing When Necessary

Over time, your wooden countertops might show signs of wear and tear.

If they start to look dull or have accumulated scratches, a light sanding and reapplication of stain or oil can restore their original beauty.

This is typically a simple process and can be done every few years or as needed to keep your countertops looking as good as new.

By following these maintenance tips, your wooden countertops will continue to be a functional and beautiful feature in your South Lyon home.

Elevate Your Home with Tribble Painting Company

Discover the transformative power of expertly stained wood or butcher block countertops.

This guide has equipped you with the knowledge to enhance the beauty and longevity of your kitchen surfaces.

Tribble Painting Company is your go-to expert for all your wood staining and house painting needs, ensuring professional results that elevate the charm of your South Lyon home.

Our expertise extends beyond just painting; we’re masters in the art of wood staining, bringing out the best in your wooden countertops.

Trust in Tribble Painting Company to deliver quality, durability, and style, seamlessly blending with your home’s unique character.

Ready to take your home’s aesthetics to the next level?

Fill out our contact form today, or give us a call.

Let Tribble Painting Company transform your space with the perfect blend of beauty and functionality.

You May Also Like To Know

Share the Post:

Related Posts